Howard Johnson's

Howard Deering Johnson was born on February 2, 1897 in Dorchester, Massachusetts and moved with his family to Quincy, Massachusetts in 1899. He left school in the eighth grade to work for his father, who owned a small cigar store and manufacturing company.

After serving in World War I, Johnson returned to Quincy and in 1925 borrowed $2500 to purchase a small drugstore at 89 Beale Street. He sold newspapers, magazines and cigars, and had a marble soda fountain with three flavors of ice cream — vanilla, chocolate and strawberry.

To ensure his drugstore would be a success, Johnson developed an ice cream recipe with double the butterfat. His rich, creamy ice cream was flavored with all-natural ingredients and the quality and taste never varied. He formulated twenty-eight flavors and was quoted as saying, "I thought I had every flavor in the world."
 

Howard Johnson's, 89 Beale Street, Quincy, Massachusetts

Throughout the summers of the late 1920s, Johnson opened concession stands on beachfront property along the coast of Massachusetts. The first was opened in 1926 on Wollaston Beach, where he paid $300 for the privilege of selling ice cream from a twenty-two foot stand. He sold $60,000 worth of ice cream cones that summer — 14,000 cones on one Sunday.
 

Howard Johnson's Ice Cream Stand, Wollaston Beach, 1926

In 1929, Johnson opened a sit-down restaurant in Quincy Square's Granite Trust Building. He served traditional New England foods, including roast turkey, steaks and chops, chicken pot pies, baked macaroni and cheese, baked beans and, of course, twenty-eight flavors of ice cream.

In the summer of 1935, the first franchised Howard Johnson's restaurant opened on Cape Cod. By the fall of 1940, Johnson had more than 130 restaurants throughout New England in one-story white colonial-style buildings, with dormered orange porcelain tile roofs, turquoise blue shutters and a cupola with a Simple Simon and the Pieman weathervane — all with standardized menus and ice cream dishes.
 

Prototype Howard Johnson's Restaurant, late 1930s

Maintaining consistent quality at each Howard Johnson’s location was made possible by an enormous commissary system of centralized kitchens, which produced, froze and distributed much of the food to individual restaurants. Franchisees strictly adhered to the minutely detailed preparations laid out in the Howard Johnson's Bible.

By 1953, there were 353 Howard Johnson's restaurants, all east of the Mississippi. In the spring of 1954, the first Howard Johnson's west of the Mississippi opened in Missouri — at 10460 St Charles Rock Road in St. Ann.

Over the next two years, three more Howard Johnson restaurants opened in the St. Louis area — at 7950 Clayton Road in Richmond Heights, at 1130 South Kirkwood Road in Kirkwood, and at 6935 South Lindbergh in Mehlville. And by the end of the decade there were restaurants at 8609 Watson in Webster Groves and 3501 North Kingshighway in North St. Louis.

The new restaurants all had a more contemporary design, which would become the standard for Howard Johnson's restaurants and their most famous and recognizable design. The restaurants were sleek single-story structures, surrounded by large plate-glass windows. There was a sloping orange tile hip roof, topped with the trademark cupola and Simple Simon weathervane.
 

Mid 1950s Howard Johnson's Restaurant

Inside the new restaurants, rustic traditional seating was replaced with minimalist benches; Formica tabletops replaced wood tables. There were terrazzo floors, acoustic ceilings, birch trim and pink tinted mirrors.
 

Howard Johnson's Dining Room, 1960s

A Formica counter with orange stools was usually to the right as one entered a Howard Johnson's restaurant. A customer could have a quick snack, a cup of coffee or a dish of ice cream here rather than a full meal in the main dining room, usually to the left. A mirrored backboard displayed the Simple Simon and the Pieman logo, plus the twenty-eight flavors of ice cream.
 

Howard Johnson's Counter, 1950s
Howard Johnson's Counter, 1990s

The twenty-eight flavors of ice cream that Howard Johnson settled on became the backbone of his business. In 1949, he sold more than 3 million gallons, 85% of which were vanilla, chocolate or strawberry. The list remained constant at twenty-eight, with each new promising concoction replacing a failing flavor.
 

1. Vanilla 8. Butter Crunch 15. Frozen Pudding 22. Coconut
2. Chocolate 9. Banana 16. Macaroon 23. Fruit Salad
3. Chocolate Chip 10. Peach 17. Orange-Pineapple 24. Lemon
4. Strawberry 11. Peppermint 18. Pecan Brittle 25. Grape Nut
5. Coffee 12. Burgundy Cherry 19. Butterscotch 26. Peanut Brittle
6. Maple Walnut 13. Butter Pecan 20. Black Raspberry 27. Ginger
7. Pistachio 14. Caramel Fudge 21. Pineapple 28. Apple

The twenty-eight flavors ranked by popularity

There were also four fruit-flavored sherbets offered — orange, raspberry, lime and lemon.
 

1950s Howard Johnson's Ice Cream Menu
(click image to enlarge)

However, it wasn't just twenty-eight flavors of ice cream that brought customers back to Howard Johnson's. It was also their delicious fried clams, touted as being "sweet as a nut" and native to New England.

In 1951, Howard Johnson's introduced the "clam strip" to the public. Clams were shucked and their large digging muscles removed. They were then cut into thin strips and fried. Since they were fried without their bellies, the sweet flavor was more appealing to a larger customer base. They were trademarked as "Tendersweet" clams.
 

Howard Johnson's Advertisement

Clam chowder was also a mainstay on the Howard Johnson's menu. Jacques Pepin, a young French chef, was hired by Johnson to work in New York, testing recipes to be used throughout the country. Pepin perfected the clam chowder, which was made from the discarded bellies in the fried clams preparation. The chowder was made in 3,000-gallon quantities.

Another popular menu item was Howard Johnson's grilled "frankfort." All-beef frankfurters were clipped at both ends, notched lengthwise and grilled in creamery butter. They were then placed in a butter-toasted roll and served in a paper sleeve.
 

Howard Johnson's Grilled Frankfort
 
1950s Howard Johnson's Menu
(click image to enlarge)

In the 1960s, four additional Howard Johnson's restaurants opened in the greater St. Louis area — at 9085 Dunn Road in Hazelwood, 9301 Lewis & Clark in Jennings, 611 North Lindbergh in Creve Coeur and 1425 South Fifth Street in St. Charles. Two more restaurants opened in the 1970s at 5915 Wilson in Midtown St. Louis and 12322 Dorsett Road in Maryland Heights.
 

1964 Howard Johnson's Menu
(click image to enlarge)

Howard Johnson's was among the first family-friendly restaurants, offering special menus for children with meals such as the Peter Piper Plate, the Humpty Dumpty Lunch and the Simple Simon Special. Menus were designed as baseball caps, the Easter Bunny and Santa Clause. There was also an Ice Cream Game which offered a free ice cream cone once all twenty-eight flavors of ice cream had been ordered and twenty-eight boxes checked.
 

Howard Johnson's Children's Menu
(click image to enlarge)

By the late 1970s, while there were more than 1000 Howard Johnson's restaurants throughout the country, fast food chains like McDonald’s had begun to devour market share with inexpensive menus.

The Howard Johnson's in Webster Groves had become a Steak 'n Shake by 1972. The restaurant on North Kinshighway had closed in 1973 and would become a Kentucky Fried Chicken.

In 1976, the Howard Johnson's on Lindbergh in Creve Coeur was purchased by Port St. Louis owner Wade DeWoskin and converted to Wade's, a Gathering Place. It would later become a KC Masterpiece BBQ location.

The Maryland Heights Howard Johnson's became Roma's in 1980. The St. Charles Rock Road location in St. Ann would close in 1981 and become a Shoney's. The South Lindbergh restaurant in Mehlville became Victoria's Ice Creamery in 1984.

In 1984, Harry Giessow, who owned both the Howard Johnson's in Kirkwood and the restaurant on Clayton Road in Richmond Heights, converted the Clayton Road location to Layton's.

In 1987, the Howard Johnson's on Dunn Road in Hazelwood became a Dohack's, the midtown location off of Hampton became a Marriott, the restaurant in St. Charles became a Ramada Inn and the Jennings location was liquidated.

*     *     *     *     *

By April of 2002, there were less than 20 Howard Johnson's restaurants remaining in the United States and only one west of the Mississippi — the orange-roofed restaurant in Kirkwood.

The Hoard Johnson's at 1130 South Kirkwood Road was built by Harry Giessow in 1955. His son, Gary Giessow, later became the owner and operator for many years. By 2002, the restaurant was owned by Michael Van Stavern.

The restaurant's general manager was working on a concept to keep the old favorites on the menu — the fried clams and the frankforts — and combine them with more contemporary cuisine. "Our goal is to be around for a long time," he said. "We want to bring the restaurant into the 2000s. We hope to keep our older clientele while bringing in younger people."

On October 21, 2002, the Kirkwood Howard Johnson's closed without fanfare. "We just ran of of food," said Van Stavern.

Outside, Simple Simon and the Pieman still twirled atop the weathervane on the cupola. The chain's logo also graced a stone wall. But the eraser board that had advertised daily specials read: "Out of Business."
 

Kirkwood Howard Johnson's, 1993

The last Howard Johnson's restaurant on the planet closed its doors in the sleepy resort town of Lake George, New York in 2017.


Copyright © 2020 LostTables.com
Lost TablesTM is a trademark of LostTables.com. All rights reserved.